Director: Marie Kreutzer
Cast: Léa Seydoux, Jella Haase, Laurence Rupp, Malo Blanchet, Anton Rubtsov, Nils Strunk, Sylvester Groth, Patrycja Ziółkowska, Regina Fritsch, Catherine Deneuve
Screenplay: Marie Kreutzer
115 mins. Rated R for sexuality, graphic nudity and some language.

As Netflix ramps up their award season, expect to see a myriad of films flow in over the next few weeks, making it difficult to decide exactly what to see in the flurry. Without a doubt, make Gentle Monster something for your watchlist, the new film from director Marie Kreutzer (Corsage). Never an easy experience, Gentle Monster is an ethical relationship drama featuring stunning work from a never-better Léa Seydoux (Dune: Part Two) in a performance wrecked me with its raw, incalculable sadness and uncertainty in a situation none of us would expect.

Lucy Weiss (Seydoux) is a successful pianist who has, with her family, moved out to the countryside in support of her husband Philip (Laurence Rupp, Mission: Impossible – Rogue Nation) after he suffers from burnout, which puts an damper on her career progression. Everything seems great until a special police investigator shows up at their door with a search warrant, seizing up all computers and electronic devices. Lucy learns that Philip has been charged with distribution of child sexual assault material. Now, she has to reckon with these accusations and try to come to terms with the man she’s married while the investigator deals with her own learned truths about her father’s behavior with his live-in nurse.

To put it simply: this movie belongs to the career-best work of Léa Seydoux; everyone in her orbit just falls away every time she’s on screen. While the subject material is harrowing and difficult but nevertheless compelling, Seydoux is just on another level with a cold, fearful, always at battle with herself performance that will come to define her strengths as an actor. Rupp also has a difficult role to play, and he’s able to give subtle work that makes it hard to understand if this is simply a misunderstanding that has landed him here or something sinister. The interplay between the two of them is thrilling and everything one could want from their cast.

Gentle Monster is indeed two stories running concurrently, and I put more emphasis on the tale of Lucy and Philip over the story of Elsa (Jella Haase, Suck Me Shakespeer), the investigator dealing accusations of attempted sexual assault from her father upon his live-in nurse, and the reason why is simple: this secondary story is simply not compelling enough on its own, and it seems that Kreutzer knew that, giving a bulk of the screen presence to Lucy and Philip. Every time the narrative shifts to Elsa’s personal story, the movie struggles to maintain momentum. I know what Kreutzer is going for here with the multiple murky narratives that intertwine, showing how deeply set these problems are in a society, and how every single woman knows someone who has committed terrible acts, but it simply doesn’t have the weight it needs to, and the Lucy/Philip story is just more effective throughout.

Gentle Monster is a painful and difficult film by design, one that presents a complex situation where it becomes difficult to discern truth from lies, made all the more important by the inclusion of a small child in the relationship. It features the best work ever by Seydoux, an already incredible actress prior to this film, but including the subplot with the investigator and her father, while included with good intentions, completely unnecessary in the finished product, taking screen time away from the much more interesting main plot which could have benefitted from more time to flesh out its third act. This is not an easy watch, but for those willing to step into the murky material, it’s a fulfilling and intelligent drama well worth their time.

3½/5
-Kyle A. Goethe

Leave a Reply

Trending