Short reviews for Whistle, American Doctor, Wildwood, Wicker, and Forbidden Fruits

Whistle
When a group of high schoolers discover an Aztec Death Whistle in the locker of a recently-deceased student, they trigger a curse that guides their individual predetermined deaths to them, one at a time. Corin Hardy’s Whistle has a lot going for it: a few notable faces that do a lot with the material, Hardy’s signature visual flair, and some truly gruesome and bloody sequences all surrounding an interesting story hook and central prop. Unfortunately, an overreliance on CGI over practical effects takes a lot of the narliness from Whistle, and in the back half it becomes clear how little thought went into establishing the rules of this mythical death whistle as a number of plot conveniences and unexplained story points make themselves all too apparent. There’s enough here to establish what could be a fun little franchise, but the rules and mythology need to be better established going forward. This one also struggles from poor editing choices that string together shots in a clunky way and a pacing that somehow gets worse as the body count increases, which is kind of baffling. Still, I enjoyed Dafne Keen in the lead (she’s delightfully 90s), and adding Nick Frost to your genre outing is never a bad idea. I wanted to like this one more, but the ending sours it, but there’s plenty of hope for learning how to make a better sequel.
Whistle: 2½/5
-Kyle A. Goethe

American Doctor
This documentary follows three American doctors of Palestinian, Jewish, and Zoroastrian descent, as they work to save lives in Gaza while also speaking for their patients and the atrocities to the United States media, sharing their experiences and trying to raise awareness. American Doctor is a rather swiftly moving little documentary that relays these three men and their attempts to do the right thing in Gaza and at home, and it’s full of difficult and disturbing imagery, but it’s also extremely necessary to convey what’s going on in Gaza so that people around the world see the horrors being afflicted. The movie pulls no punches and documents events quite well, using these three men to be the storytellers and share what they go through, and director Poh Si Teng (Busted) takes cues from medical dramas like The Pitt to put viewers right in the middle of the quick decision-making and stressful situations of the health care works just trying to do as much as they can. As stated in the film, these doctors have seen more than most Americans, and they know what information is not making it back to the United States, so there is a lot of discussion about the number of children being shot and blown up and killed and the bombing of hospitals, a big breaking with International Law. Even the doctors, like Thaer Ahmad, are occasionally being stopped from entering the area because of their Palestinian descent, and Mark Perlmutter is heartbroken and angry about the situation, speaking on behalf of the dead patients who cannot. It’s a powerful documentary, one of the more focused and revelatory films to come out of the Gaza area in recent years.
American Doctor: 4/5
-Kyle A. Goethe

Wildwood
When adolescent Prue’s baby brother is abducted by a murder of crows, she and her classmate Curtis follows them into the Impassable Wilderness, known as “Wildwood” to its inhabitants. Now, Prue and Curtis have been separated, and they’ve unknowingly found themselves at the center of a major mythical conflict over the control of Wildwood. There’s a reason so many people are talking about a stop-motion movie that’s underperforming at the box office despite its acclaim. Wildwood is the REAL DEAL, folks, one of the most exquisitely and carefully handcrafted pieces of animation I’ve ever seen. It doesn’t surprise me that the film took so many years to accomplish, and when I did the math, it seemed to me that worked pretty fast to accomplish every movement and frame of the picture. The large scale battle scenes are stunning and so full of detail that the film will require multiple viewings to truly appreciate. It’s an absolute achievement in the world of animation film making. The story is well put together albeit a little familiar, but this is a case of “It’s not the story, It’s how you tell it,” and with this attention to the animation and the comfortability to really hit the emotional core and test its audience, Wildwood rises above some of its well-tread story. The creature effects and action set pieces will have those of us who actually see the film talking for plenty of time to come, and this will be, without a doubt, one of those movies that hits a streaming service in a few months only to be viewed as “How did we miss this in theaters?” For those of you complaining about the lack of original ideas in Hollywood, you don’t really get to be upset if you didn’t watch Wildwood when you had the chance.
Wildwood: 4/5
-Kyle A. Goethe

Wicker
When a fisherwoman is tired of her village’s jabs at her spinster lifestyle, she requests the local basketmaker to make her a wicker husband. Now, the whole village is up in arms at the very notion of it, and the legends of the carnality and bed-breaking activities of the fisherwoman and her hubby have made it to the gossip circles, causing the tailor’s wife to target this couple with her devious schemes. The thirst is real with this one, and thankfully there’s a cure for mold. In this fantasy fable, Olivia Colman and Alexander Skarsgard make for the unlikeliest of romances between a fisherwoman and her animated wicker husband, and it worked so well. Embracing the fable’s origins, the filmmakers behind this one turned up the naughtiness to 11 and made a raunchy but entirely believable and relatable love story that turns an entire community upside down. I loved that the real conflict comes from the town instead of the central relationship because life is a lot easier when your relationship is a mutual support system, like the one between Colman and Skarsgard. It’s also a pretty funny movie, never taking itself too seriously until a few key emotional beats that didn’t altogether surprise me (the movie has a pretty simple plot and trajectory throughout most of it, at least once you accept the concept) but worked nonetheless. Having a town consume itself over jealousy instead of recognize their own inherent flaws is perhaps the most connected to the real world Wicker ever gets. I wish the final scenes had more impact, but altogether, Wicker is a bold and very fun experience that should make for a good date night.
Wicker: 4/5
-Kyle A. Goethe

Forbidden Fruits
Employees at the mall shop Free Eden, led by Apple, partake in witch and occult practices in the store after hours, and when new hire Pumpkin is brought into the fold, the coven begins to consume itself from within with secrets, betrayals, and toxic brutality. Forbidden Fruits spreads itself thin with its generational horror/comedy elements centered at this mall store, but it can’t find its footing and never feels narratively cohesive. The performances are all good, but the screenplay just juggles a lot of ideas around and never fully commits to one of them. Instead, we get a movie with a lot of things happening, but there’s really no plot at all, just fluff and style, which the movie has a lot of. The makeup and costumes and cinematography is all solid, but the nonsensical and directionless story is lacking everything, and there’s no flow from scene to scene. Had writer/director Meredith Alloway streamlined and simplified her thoughts for the film into a narrative that built upon itself, Forbidden Fruits could likely have been much better (she’s a pretty damn good visual artist), but the script is all over the place. As it stands, the movie is a disaster.
Forbidden Fruits: 1½/5
-Kyle A. Goethe
- For more Corin Hardy: The Nun
- For more Travis Knight: Kubo and the Two Strings, Masters of the Universe


![[Early Review] How to Rob a Bank (2026)](https://goatfilmreviews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/how-to-rob-a-bank.jpg?w=1024)
![[TCFF 2026] Josephine (2026)](https://goatfilmreviews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/josephine-still_1.jpg?w=600)
![[TCFF 2026] Elsinore (2026)](https://goatfilmreviews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/e_03144_r.jpg?w=1024)
Leave a Reply